A recent Workplace Relations Commission decision has highlighted the risks employers face when workplace concerns are not handled appropriately. A former employee of a Donegal-based company was awarded more than €44,000 after raising concerns about CCTV installation procedures and subsequently experiencing what the WRC found to be penalisation and constructive dismissal.
CCTV Concerns and Protected Disclosures
The employee raised concerns after CCTV cameras were installed in the workplace without prior consultation or clear communication with staff. He questioned whether the process complied with data protection obligations and refused to sign documentation acknowledging the installation.
The employer argued that the cameras had been installed for security reasons following thefts on site and maintained that the measures complied with GDPR requirements. However, the employee believed staff had not been properly informed and sought external advice regarding the issue.
Under the Protected Disclosures Act 2014, employees are protected from penalisation when they raise concerns about potential wrongdoing in the workplace. Importantly, these protections can apply even where an employer disputes the complaint itself.
Internal Messages and Reduced Working Hours
During the hearing, internal WhatsApp messages between members of management were examined. The messages referred negatively to the employee and described him as creating problems within the business due to his objections.
Shortly after these exchanges took place, the employee was informed that his working hours would be significantly reduced due to what the employer described as reduced operational demand.
The WRC noted the timing of these events and found there was a direct connection between the employee raising concerns and the subsequent reduction in his hours.
WRC Findings and Compensation
The adjudicator concluded that the employee had been penalised for making a protected disclosure and awarded compensation equivalent to approximately one year’s pay under the Protected Disclosures Act.
The WRC also found that the unilateral reduction in hours entitled the employee to consider himself constructively dismissed under the Unfair Dismissals Act 1977. Additional compensation was awarded relating to working time documentation requirements.
In total, compensation exceeding €44,000 was awarded.
Key Lessons for Employers
This case serves as an important reminder that employers must approach workplace complaints carefully and professionally, particularly where employees raise concerns linked to legal compliance or data protection.
Employers should ensure that CCTV policies are transparent, GDPR obligations are followed, and employees are properly informed about workplace monitoring measures. Equally important is ensuring that employees who raise concerns are not treated unfairly or subjected to adverse treatment afterwards.
Clear policies, proper communication, and fair procedures remain essential in reducing legal risk and maintaining trust within the workplace.